Normally said given that visual license to your author’s area
Often when times are given, he or she is given that have day of the times one does not suits with this go out because in the real records. One such analogy occurs in Harry Potter and Prisoner off Azkaban when Sybill Trelawney describes sixteen Oct since Monday, even though sixteen October 1993 try a tuesday.
There are even contradictions in books of this type. Eg, from inside the Harry Potter and also the Cup out of Fire, each other step 1 Sep and you can dos September are provided since the Mondays and, from inside the Harry Potter and the Prisoner from Azkaban, Buckbeak’s demo is decided toward 20 April, however, careful parsing of text message demonstrates that it might possess happened no later on than just March.
Together with, in the Harry Potter plus the Goblet off Flame it is said that the Winners were selected towards Monday 31 October, but 31 Oct was a tuesday when you look at the 1994.
In the chapter 7 off Quidditch From the Decades, it is said your very first Quidditch World Mug happened in the 1473. When your tournament is actually stored the couple of years, this disputes to your report in the Cup of Fire that 1994 Industry Cup is actually the latest 422nd. When the Quidditch Through the Ages is useful, the nettside newest 422nd Quidditch Industry Cup do in reality fall-in the entire year 3161, however, if Cup of Flame is great, the original World Cup ended up being kept in the 306.
Historical troubles [ ]
As the show, according to schedule derived from brand new Chamber out of Secrets source, is determined from the 1990s, new series tend to seems as though it’s set in new later 1990s to help you mid-2000s, approximately concurrent towards the book of your own courses. When you look at the Harry Potter as well as the 50 % of-Blood Prince, Cornelius Fudge spends a masculine pronoun to mention toward “predecessor” of the Finest Minister of British. Depending on the significantly more than timeline, this should take place in the summertime from 1996, if the Perfect Minister is John Biggest, whose instant predecessor is actually a woman (‘s earliest meeting with Fudge, the publication says the fresh new election, but Biggest was not first opted for and simply got over shortly after Thatcher retired.
You will be able, but not impractical, that Fudge would be speaing frankly about a far more distant ancestor, since Thatcher got work environment before Fudge purportedly became Minister for Wonders. (Even though one can think a situation where Fudge is actually delegated by Minister getting Secret in order to satisfy into Prime Minister as he, Fudge, was a student in an inferior office.) On top of that, brand new identity and you will reputation for the prime Minister represented seems to so much more directly meets regarding Tony Blair than just of John Big. A blog post regarding the Every day Mail notes one Rowling are romantic toward upcoming-Chancellor of Exchequer Gordon Brownish (usually considered a rival so you’re able to Blair’s frontrunners of your Labor People, just who succeeded your and you will turned into Perfect Minister), hence she might have been attempting to inform you Blair’s terrible front side. If the guides was basically invest sync which have publication time out-of Philosopher’s Brick, then so it enjoy would occur in 2002 (once Blair turned into Finest Minister).
not, it absolutely was later on stated that 22 November was a saturday, that it was a student in 1994
The same disease comes to Nicolas Flamel, who had been said as actually 665 at the time of the newest very first guide, but Nicolas Flamel are a real historic contour and you may would not reach one to age up until 1996, within the date the first publication try published. The fresh new rebuttal for it is the fact that time the new “real” Nicolas Flamel came to be cannot keep in touch with the Nicolas Flamel out-of Harry Potter.
A different sort of condition is obtainable away from Rubeus Hagrid’s period once the Hogwarts’s gamekeeper. It is required in the collection that Hagrid got you to position within a few years regarding his expulsion away from school within the 1942. However in one world off Harry Potter and the Cup away from Flame, Molly Weasley reminisces in the Ogg, Hagrid’s preekeeper apparently convergence having Molly’s ages at school, it appears to be unlikely one to she remembers a previous gamekeeper. Yet not, you’ll be able to one to Hagrid didn’t end up being a beneficial gamekeeper instantly after becoming expelled, but instead started as Ogg’s assistant. This really is possible since when Harry believes which he have a tendency to be expelled to possess flying towards the broomstick versus permission within his first year, he magic if the he would be permitted to stay on as the Hagrid’s secretary.